As the holiday season winds to a close, I have been making some observations I thought I would share with you fellas out there.
Also, I have done a fair share of research on the topic.
You see, I have two young daughters; one seven, and the other almost four. While they love their kid shows and videos, if Mom turns on the TV, they come running. They know what’s happening.
Mom’s watching a “girl” movie.
Yes, I confess this educated, literary, tea-drinking, high-brow drama mama is a sucker for a Hallmark movie. In fact, most of the women I know are. But why? Why do even my baby girls get drawn in by these unashamedly low-production value flicks with mediocre acting and recycled plots?
1. Women want to be seen.
There is nothing better in a romantic movie than a googly-eyed gaze, and these movies always deliver. The male leads are always sneaking glances or lingering eye contact at their ingenues. And then there’s the scene, be it dance, ball, or date, where our heroine gets all dolled up and turns all the heads. She is lovely and captivating, and it is an empowering feeling.
The desire for this feeling is an innate need. It is Adam waking up from rib surgery and standing in amazement at Eve. It is my daughters running to Daddy for approval anytime they fix their hair or change their outfits. Women want to be told not only they are beautiful, but they are worthy of love and have the power to captivate.
2. Women want to be known.
Do you ever notice how the hero and heroine manage to fall in love in the space of time between Thanksgiving and Christmas? Okay, so not all of these cheesy romances are holiday movies, but even so – a few weeks, maybe a month, and they are practically engaged (or actually engaged, or married!)! Of course it isn’t realistic, but it becomes conceivable because the hero gets to know the heroine – actually know her. He listens. He pays attention. He goes out of his way to understand her and reach her. This is true intimacy, and is the key to a woman’s heart. It is Hagar in the desert at her lowest place and God reaching out, saying, “I am the God who sees you.” He knows her story and her struggles and wants to meet her there. A woman feels secure when someone is interested and invested in her.
3. Women want the magic.
Put down the pitchfork, Puritans, I don’t mean that kind of magic. All of these movies, just like fairytales and myths, contain an element of the supernatural. Whether they call it fate or destiny or Christmas spirit, there are forces beyond the natural at work to bring people together and put things right. While I would not say it is exclusive to women, I believe humans are built for the supernatural because we are spirit. There is that thing deep down that knows quantitative reality is only part of the picture. We want to believe in a divine and beneficent force at work, even if we are too vague or obtuse to name it.
4. Women want family.
That statement is not a political manifesto or misogynistic stereotyping. Family is a basic human need, and women, as natural nurturers, feel it more distinctly. In nearly every one of these movies, there is an element of going home or restoring family relations. Where there is not biological family, there are work families or community families. People need people; they need a support system and a safe place. So, the restoration of family in these movies satisfies a human emotion in the viewer which is desperately needed in our increasingly individualistic world.
5. Women want a happy ending.
With Shakespeare’s tragedies, everyone dies. Comedies, however, mean everyone gets married. He knew how to please an audience. In these movies, you can count on happy ending. No surprises, no tragedies, no disappointments. No, it isn’t realistic, and that’s the point. Women in particular bear a good deal of real life struggles, particularly in people relationships. I remember trying to watch any dramatic movie after I had my first child and simply being unable to recover from or even finish many. The real world is full of heartache, but what we need is hope. That happy ending restores our resilience and helps us see the possibility of good triumphing over evil.
So, then, why should the men of the world take notice? The old adage says, “Happy wife, happy life.” But it is more than that: women have biological and emotional needs (just as men do), and, instead of laughing it off, you can accept the challenge. Gaze a little longer, know her favorite book and what her passions are, make family and friends a priority, and give her hope for the hard days.
And watch one with her – you might like it.